Updated Week 17 Start/Sit Advice for Tyler Warren, Jake Tonges, Theo Johnson, and Others

Looking for an edge at tight end in Week 17? With injuries and disappointing early performances thinning out the position, hungry fantasy football managers need to hit the waiver wire for upside and volume. If stability and upside are what’s needed, these are the tight ends who could tip the scales in Week 17 fantasy matchups.

These rankings were last updated at 7:00 AM ET on Sunday, December 28, 2025.

Check out the FREE Start/Sit Optimizer from PFSN to ensure you are making the right decisions for your fantasy lineup every week!

Week 17 Fantasy TE Rankings

1) Trey McBride | Arizona Cardinals (at CIN)
2) Harold Fannin Jr. | Cleveland Browns (vs. PIT)
3) Kyle Pitts Sr. | Atlanta Falcons (vs. LAR)
4) Dallas Goedert | Philadelphia Eagles (at BUF)
5) Juwan Johnson | New Orleans Saints (at TEN)
6) Dalton Schultz | Houston Texans (at LAC)
7) Tyler Warren | Indianapolis Colts (vs. JAX)
8) Brenton Strange | Jacksonville Jaguars (at IND)
9) Jake Ferguson | Dallas Cowboys (at WAS)
10) Colston Loveland | Chicago Bears (at SF)
11) Hunter Henry | New England Patriots (at NYJ)
12) Travis Kelce | Kansas City Chiefs (vs. DEN)
13) Darren Waller | Miami Dolphins (vs. TB)
14) Jake Tonges | San Francisco 49ers (vs. CHI)
15) Michael Mayer | Las Vegas Raiders (vs. NYG)
16) Colby Parkinson | Los Angeles Rams (at ATL)
17) Oronde Gadsden II | Los Angeles Chargers (vs. HOU)
18) Theo Johnson | New York Giants (at LV)
19) Terrance Ferguson | Los Angeles Rams (at ATL)
20) AJ Barner | Seattle Seahawks (at CAR)
21) Cade Otton | Tampa Bay Buccaneers (at MIA)
22) Mark Andrews | Baltimore Ravens (at GB)
23) Mike Gesicki | Cincinnati Bengals (vs. ARI)
24) Josh Oliver | Minnesota Vikings (vs. DET)
25) Elijah Higgins | Arizona Cardinals (at CIN)
26) Dalton Kincaid | Buffalo Bills (vs. PHI)
27) Isaiah Likely | Baltimore Ravens (at GB)
28) Evan Engram | Denver Broncos (at KC)
29) Gunnar Helm | Tennessee Titans (vs. NO)
30) Chig Okonkwo | Tennessee Titans (vs. NO)

Darren Waller, TE, Miami Dolphins (vs. TB)

It wasn’t the smash we were hoping for against the worst TE defense of all time last week, but Darren Waller continues to be involved in the Miami Dolphins’ offense. He caught three passes for 40 yards, which is not the worst outing from the tight end position.

Waller still only played about half the snaps, but he did lead the tight ends. And the reality is, we’re chasing a touchdown with Waller anyway.

This week is another favorable spot for the Dolphins’ passing game, especially for Waller. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers allow the sixth-most fantasy points per game to tight ends. Quinn Ewers exceeded the admittedly very low bar set for him against the Bengals. The Dolphins should be trailing and throwing. Waller is a fine option who has a decent floor even if he doesn’t find the end zone.

Brenton Strange, TE, Jacksonville Jaguars (vs. IND)

The Jaguars’ offense is pretty simple. Who is Trevor Lawrence going to look for? Anyone other than Brian Thomas Jr.

Lawrence is playing not just the best football of his career, but some of the best football we’ve seen from any quarterback this season. Jakobi Meyers is the clear WR1 and his favorite target, but behind him, there’s no clear No. 2. Except, of course, it’s definitely not Thomas.

Last week, Lawrence found both Parker Washington and Brenton Strange. The tight end has been a mixed bag since returning from IR, but he does have 13+ fantasy points in three of his last five games.

The Colts are a pass funnel defense. They’re slightly below average at defending the tight end, allowing the 12th-most fantasy points per game to the position. Strange is easily a top 12 TE this week.

Should You Start or Sit Warren in Week 17?

Tyler Warren’s fantasy production has very much hit a wall (three games under seven PPR points), but with his target share increasing each game over that stretch, there is a path for him to make it back to the top-12 sooner than later.

That said, this offense is struggling with consistency, and that’s held the versatile rookie to just one end zone target over his past eight games.

Warren isn’t the auto-start he once was, and he caught just two passes on 37 routes in this meeting in Week 14. There’s risk to weigh, but that’s the case for roughly 25 of the starting tight ends in the league.

Sign me up for a TE13 ranking, in that Jake Ferguson (at WAS) and Hunter Henry (at NYJ) tier.

Are you looking for start/sit advice for other players in your lineup? Read our Fantasy Football Start ‘Em, Sit ‘Em Cheat Sheet.

Leave a Comment